Page 3 of 3

Re: Multi SFP Switch

Posted: Fri Nov 30, 2018 11:54 am
by glennorton
+1 bump for this. We have immediate need for an SFP+ replacement to the WS-12-250-AC and 400-AC. I would love to see 4port SFP cage models as well for our non-wisp needs.

To the guy that said there are other switch brands out there with these capabilities, yes there are. But not anywhere near the same price point, or smaller sizes that are needed for mounting at the top of towers. There is a big difference in the size of box needed to house a 9"x7" switch vs 17"x15" switch.
A bit more wind load to consider.

And also, we just like the Netonix switches! There is a lot to be said about being able to stick with one vendor for all our switching needs. It makes keeping spares easier, and we have a backup system in place that would have to be completely reworked for a different switch brand. So yes, there ARE needs for more switches even though there are vendor other options out there.

Chris, you've got my email please let me know when these are available for order! Thanks,
--
glen

Re: Multi SFP Switch

Posted: Wed Apr 03, 2019 3:28 pm
by tomtech
I just saw this thread, and I know its old, but hey, why not?
We have been doing more fiber than ever, both in towers, and in the municipal work were doing. We are often connecting dark fiber for small cities in outdoor traffic cabinets. We could use a multi-port (4 or 8?) SFP switch with POE copper as well, that can manage the harsh temp extremes that Netonix does. anything we have found is at least double the price if not triple. So you got my vote of support for more fiber cages.

Thanks for the great products...

T

Re: Multi SFP Switch

Posted: Wed Apr 03, 2019 4:09 pm
by mike99
Even if it would be nice to have a single provider, the're several cheap multi SFP solution (Ubnt, Mikrotik. TP-Link, etc). I doubt netonix would invest so much money in a niche market. Chris as writen several time on this forum on ROI for every new product but maybe one day.

An other thing to think of is that ISP doing both fiber and WISP need an other brand of device anyway, by exemple for PON network. Current netonix could be feed via a PON network with a SFP PON stick. Since all SFP ports device are more core oriented, I doubt it would be that much usefull for ISP network without more L3 and/or encapsulations (MPLS, VxLAN, TRILL, MACinMAC, etc.) features.

Re: Multi SFP Switch

Posted: Mon Jan 06, 2020 1:20 pm
by salad
We're also feeling the pain of the lack of flexible switch options. As we're changing our backhauls to fiber-based (either running fiber to towers or doing SFPs in the BH radios) we're buying surplus Juniper EX4200-24F. They're nice switches but they're immense and use a lot of power - they also suck with copper SFPs.

We'd buy a pile of switches with a mix of copper, SFP, and SFP+ ports. Ideally something like 6x copper, 6x SFP, 4x SFP+. A version of the WS-12 series of switches with 4x SFP and only 10x copper would also be helpful, and I'm a little surprised that even the 26-port Netonix switches only have two SFP ports. The only other vendor that we're comfortable with that really comes close is Etherwan and they're lacking 10G, features, and the price is not suitable for these deployments.

mike99 wrote:An other thing to think of is that ISP doing both fiber and WISP need an other brand of device anyway, by exemple for PON network. Current netonix could be feed via a PON network with a SFP PON stick. Since all SFP ports device are more core oriented, I doubt it would be that much usefull for ISP network without more L3 and/or encapsulations (MPLS, VxLAN, TRILL, MACinMAC, etc.) features.


As a PON operator as well I don't see any market for such a product. The PON side is very complicated as there's a lot more to make the entire thing work than just simple VLAN tagging. Even if this product existed I would not connect it to our network.